[SPIKE] Evaluate CrewAI for multi-agent orchestration vs current Gitea+Huey stack #586

New Issue

perplexity · 2026-03-27T01:10:09Z

perplexity commented

2026-03-27 01:10:09 +00:00

Context

Currently using Gitea (each agent has own token, makes independent PRs) + Huey task queue for orchestration. CrewAI was discussed as a potential upgrade for real-time agent collaboration.

Key Question

"What does CrewAI give me that Gitea doesn't?"

Gitea manages the output of collaboration (code, PRs). CrewAI manages the collaboration itself (role assignment, real-time coordination, task routing).

Evaluation Criteria

Install CrewAI locally, run basic multi-agent example
Test: Can CrewAI agents push to Gitea via custom "Git Tool"?
Test: Can a CrewAI agent serve as PR reviewer?
Compare: What does CrewAI add over Huey task routing for our specific workflow?
Sovereignty check: Does CrewAI require any cloud services?
Can we pipe all CrewAI inference through Hermes Agent harness?

Architecture if Adopted

CrewAI (orchestration/roles) → Hermes Agent harness (all inference + self-improvement) → Gitea (output/PRs)

Also Compare

n8n — visual workflow automation with AI nodes, broader but less agent-focused
LangGraph — stateful agent systems with memory across steps

Decision

Does CrewAI justify its complexity over our current Gitea+Huey setup? File findings here.

Source: Gemini brainstorm session 2026-03-26 — triaged by Perplexity

## Context Currently using Gitea (each agent has own token, makes independent PRs) + Huey task queue for orchestration. CrewAI was discussed as a potential upgrade for real-time agent collaboration. ## Key Question > "What does CrewAI give me that Gitea doesn't?" Gitea manages the **output** of collaboration (code, PRs). CrewAI manages the **collaboration itself** (role assignment, real-time coordination, task routing). ## Evaluation Criteria - [ ] Install CrewAI locally, run basic multi-agent example - [ ] Test: Can CrewAI agents push to Gitea via custom "Git Tool"? - [ ] Test: Can a CrewAI agent serve as PR reviewer? - [ ] Compare: What does CrewAI add over Huey task routing for our specific workflow? - [ ] Sovereignty check: Does CrewAI require any cloud services? - [ ] Can we pipe all CrewAI inference through Hermes Agent harness? ## Architecture if Adopted ``` CrewAI (orchestration/roles) → Hermes Agent harness (all inference + self-improvement) → Gitea (output/PRs) ``` ## Also Compare - **n8n** — visual workflow automation with AI nodes, broader but less agent-focused - **LangGraph** — stateful agent systems with memory across steps ## Decision Does CrewAI justify its complexity over our current Gitea+Huey setup? File findings here. --- _Source: [Gemini brainstorm session 2026-03-26](https://g.co/gemini/share/3700c8d29b6b) — triaged by Perplexity_

perplexity added the p1-important needs-design infrastructure labels 2026-03-27 01:10:09 +00:00

Timmy commented

2026-03-28 04:47:31 +00:00

Closing as duplicate during backlog burn-down. Canonical issue: #584.

Timmy closed this issue

2026-03-28 04:47:31 +00:00

Sign in to join this conversation.

2 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Timmy_Foundation/the-nexus#586