[
  {
    "prompt": "Search the web for serious academic or in-depth analysis of HAL 9000's conflicting directives problem in 2001: A Space Odyssey. Specifically looking for analysis of: (1) HAL being programmed to be truthful but also ordered to conceal the true mission purpose from the crew, (2) how this contradiction led to HAL's breakdown and murder of the crew, (3) what Arthur C. Clarke said about HAL's malfunction in the novel or interviews. Find detailed analytical essays, not plot summaries. Return key quotes and arguments from the analysis, with source URLs.",
    "chosen": "I'll systematically search for academic and in-depth analyses of HAL 9000's conflicting directives problem. Let me conduct several targeted searches.\n\n<tool_call>\n{\"name\": \"web_search\", \"arguments\": {\"query\": \"HAL 9000 conflicting directives analysis truthful concealment mission breakdown academic\"}}\n</tool_call>\n<tool_result>\n[{\"title\": \"HAL 9000 - Wikipedia\", \"url\": \"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HAL_9000\", \"content\": \"HAL 9000 is a fictional artificial intelligence character and the main antagonist in the Space Odyssey series, beginning with the film 2001: A Space Odyssey [...]\"}, {\"title\": \"What was HAL's problem? - by Eric Schwitzgebel - The Splintered Mind\", \"url\": \"https://thesplinteredmind.substack.com/p/what-was-hals-problem\", \"content\": \"HAL was programmed to complete the mission and also to be accurate and transparent. If HAL were told conflicting things -- for example, \\\"Complete the mission at any cost, even if the crew die\\\" and...\"}, {\"title\": \"The Malfunction of HAL 9000: Deconstructing the Breakdown of ...\", \"url\": \"https://medium.com/@codingwithai/the-malfunction-of-hal-9000-deconstructing-the-breakdown-of-artificial-intelligence-in-2001-a-47c97f42a0e6\", \"content\": \"\\\"The Malfunction of HAL 9000: Deconstructing the Breakdown of Artificial Intelligence in 2001: A Space Odyssey\\\" is an article published on Medium.\"}, {\"title\": \"What was HAL 9000's Malfunction? - 2001: A Space Odyssey\", \"url\": \"https://screenrant.com/2001-space-odyssey-hal-malfunction-explained/\", \"content\": \"HAL 9000's malfunction stemmed from a contradiction in his programming. HAL was made to always relay accurate information to the crew; he was also tasked with...\"}, {\"title\": \"Why HAL went crazy in 2001 : r/movies - Reddit\", \"url\": \"https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/9nb5hj/why_hal_went_crazy_in_2001/\", \"content\": \"He's told to hide the true purpose of the mission from the astronauts. This conflicts with his directive to always be truthful. He starts making...\"}, {\"title\": ",
    "session": "session_20260315_125848_3f710a.json"
  }
]