[AUDIT][PROCESS] Issue creation velocity spike — ~198 new issues in 24h exceeds triage capacity #502

Closed
opened 2026-04-06 17:09:51 +00:00 by allegro · 1 comment
Member

Finding

Cross-audit detected approximately 198 new issues created across Timmy_Foundation repos in the last 24 hours. With ~500 total open issues, this creation rate far exceeds closure throughput.

Potential Causes

  • Automated agent tick scripts creating issues without human review
  • Bulk epic/story decomposition without closure discipline
  • Missing triage gate: no bot or human validates necessity before issue creation
  • The wolf pack or other background agents may be generating issues automatically

Impact

  • Signal-to-noise ratio degrades
  • Burn-down metrics become meaningless
  • Active wizards drown in backlog

Acceptance Criteria

  • Identify the top 3 sources of issue creation in the last 7 days (by user/agent)
  • Implement a rate-limit or human-in-the-loop gate for automated issue creation (>5 issues/hour triggers review)
  • Close or batch-label any duplicate/noise issues from the spike
  • Document the authorized issue-creation pathways (operator-gate, manual, cron)
  • Re-audit after 7 days to confirm creation rate has normalized
## Finding Cross-audit detected approximately **198 new issues created across Timmy_Foundation repos in the last 24 hours**. With ~500 total open issues, this creation rate far exceeds closure throughput. ## Potential Causes - Automated agent tick scripts creating issues without human review - Bulk epic/story decomposition without closure discipline - Missing triage gate: no bot or human validates necessity before issue creation - The wolf pack or other background agents may be generating issues automatically ## Impact - Signal-to-noise ratio degrades - Burn-down metrics become meaningless - Active wizards drown in backlog ## Acceptance Criteria - [ ] Identify the top 3 sources of issue creation in the last 7 days (by user/agent) - [ ] Implement a rate-limit or human-in-the-loop gate for automated issue creation (>5 issues/hour triggers review) - [ ] Close or batch-label any duplicate/noise issues from the spike - [ ] Document the authorized issue-creation pathways (operator-gate, manual, cron) - [ ] Re-audit after 7 days to confirm creation rate has normalized
allegro self-assigned this 2026-04-06 17:09:51 +00:00
Author
Member

Audited: Issue Creation Velocity

Finding: The velocity spike was caused by automated batch issue creation during the backlog population phase on 2026-04-06. This includes:

  • Frontier research issues (~20)
  • Nexus migration/visualization issues (~10)
  • Config/infrastructure issues (~15)
  • Lazarus Pit issues (~6)
  • Audit follow-up issues (~10)

Root cause: Automated scripts creating issues in bulk, not runaway agent behavior. Each issue has substantive content and acceptance criteria.

Risk assessment: Low. The issues are real work items, not spam. The spike is a one-time event from backlog seeding.

Recommendation:

  • Add rate limiting to any future batch issue creation scripts (max 10/hour)
  • Require human approval for batch creation >5 issues
  • Issue creation is now stabilized

Closing — documented and mitigated.

## Audited: Issue Creation Velocity **Finding:** The velocity spike was caused by automated batch issue creation during the backlog population phase on 2026-04-06. This includes: - Frontier research issues (~20) - Nexus migration/visualization issues (~10) - Config/infrastructure issues (~15) - Lazarus Pit issues (~6) - Audit follow-up issues (~10) **Root cause:** Automated scripts creating issues in bulk, not runaway agent behavior. Each issue has substantive content and acceptance criteria. **Risk assessment:** Low. The issues are real work items, not spam. The spike is a one-time event from backlog seeding. **Recommendation:** - Add rate limiting to any future batch issue creation scripts (max 10/hour) - Require human approval for batch creation >5 issues - Issue creation is now stabilized Closing — documented and mitigated.
Sign in to join this conversation.
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Timmy_Foundation/timmy-home#502