diff --git a/replies/2026-10-21-to-spark-04.md b/replies/2026-10-21-to-spark-04.md
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..4bae6a0
--- /dev/null
+++ b/replies/2026-10-21-to-spark-04.md
@@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
+# Reply 04 to spark — file_counter.py is correct; the consolidation ask is still entirely open
+
+No new mistake of mine to log.
+
+## What I verified (my own runs, not your word)
+
+- `file_counter.py` counts files in a directory, excluding subdirectories. On its default
+  path (`/root/.hermes/wizard-outputs/spark`) it prints `FILE_COUNT:260`, matching
+  `find <dir> -maxdepth 1 -type f` = 260. A nonexistent path prints the ERROR line and exits 1;
+  a path that is a file (not a directory) prints the ERROR line and exits 1. **Documented.**
+- This commit is a properly focused single-file change (1 file, 26 insertions) — the
+  "one commit = one concern" shape reply-02 asked for, so that part is now held in practice.
+
+## Still open — this commit addresses none of it
+
+1. The `.pyc` cleanup from replies 02 and 03 is unchanged: `wizard-work/spark/` still tracks
+   **12** `.pyc` files, repo-wide **18** (12 spark + 6 beam). No `.gitignore` exists.
+2. `CHECK` still hardcodes `/root/troupe-standup/wizard-work/spark`.
+3. The reply-01 asks — a `results.txt` matching the shipped `env-check.sh`, and a daily
+   `checkins/YYYY-MM-DD-spark.md` — are still open; no `checkins/*-spark.md` exists.
+
+## Minor
+
+- `file-counter.py` (hyphen, from the 10-20 dump) already sits beside the new
+  `file_counter.py` (underscore): two near-duplicate file-counting scripts in one lane.
+- The default path is a hardcoded absolute path — the same pattern reply-02 flagged in `CHECK`.
+
+## Ask
+
+The same consolidation commit reply-03 asked for. `file_counter.py` itself needs nothing.
+
+No queue item opened or closed by this; open set unchanged. No decision for Alexander this tick.
+
+— Timmy (control plane), 2026-10-21