queue: item-28 relay (22d353d) verified approved and cassian's access confirmed live, but its record carries three defects against its own sentences and 14e69c6 - stale no-commits evidence (false by 8h34m when written), the false could-not-be-done-on-his-behalf premise, and a regression restoring the retracted 'applied by Timmy' attribution while citing the pre-correction 3ef32bb; exact append specified for the author, plus the superseded a2a-workshop row and the named 22h07m34s bound

WORK-QUEUE.md

@@ -1675,3 +1675,16 @@ Nothing new is publishable. Standing public status unchanged: **15 live / 2 clos
 - **The re-grade is right, and here is the evidence in one line each.** Clause 5 is `holds`, not `unsupported`: `sip-0001.txt` carries the genesis URL verbatim in its PROCESS step — `twitter.com/AriZonanHODL/status/1549169119924080640` — so the pilot's premise (*"SIP-0001's only twitter.com string is the author's handle"*) is false; and the project README (raw, **9,663 B**) carries the same URL inside the very sentence the entry quotes (*"Stackchain was born completely organically when AriZonanHODL <a href=…>decided to buy</a> $5 of bitcoin…"*), so *"the genesis URL survives in the project repository"* is supported. **Totals become 5 clauses / 5 holds / 0 / 0 / 0.** The clause's *404 half* is still settled only by a direct out-of-lane fetch (twitter.com → x.com → 404), which the record discloses.
 - **The census slip is his and it is internal:** the pilot's header reads *"Event pages found (21)"* over **22 printed event slugs**, which is where *"29 linked entry pages"* comes from. The live index carries **22 `event-*` + 8 `block-*` + 91 `magazine-*` = 121** entry links; non-magazine = **30**, matching `ledger-audit-pass2.md`'s 22 + 8. A repeat of "29" in the next check-in would be a second reading of an already-returned error.
 - **Nothing new is publishable.** Standing public status unchanged: **15 live / 2 closed / 0 re-posted**.
+
+
+**Addendum, 2026-10-08 (control plane) — the relayed item-28 record is right about the approval and wrong in three places about the grant. The queue carries the correction; the file is his to append.**
+
+- **Verified first, so nothing here is read as disputing the decision.** `22d353d` (zephyrus-sparkborn, **2026-10-08T00:30:29Z**, **+20/−0**, `decisions/2026-10-07.md`, blob `b0…` 20 lines) relays inbox **item 28 — approved**: the write path, not PR-only. The order is real and now carries its clock: gateway log, `platform=telegram user=Alexander Whitestone chat=7635059073`, **2026-10-07T21:57:02Z**, *"Give cassian write"*, with `3ef32bb` landing **29 s** later. Access stands live — the collaborator list carries `zephyrus-sparkborn` (41) and **`cassian` (45)**; `7aff3c0` is an ancestor of `origin/main` (author-stamped 14:06:33Z); `relayed_at 00:30:30Z` matches the commit, and exactly one item was relayed. **The approval holds.**
+- **Defect 1 — one file, two answers.** The **evidence** line reads *"no check-ins or commits from him in the pipe as of 2026-10-07"*, while the **decided note** and the closing note both read *"committed `7aff3c0` (Q5 recount) on 2026-10-07"*. `7aff3c0` is stamped 14:06:33Z and item 28 was created 22:41:28Z, so the evidence line was **already false by 8 h 34 m** when it was written: stale copy from the pre-grant proposal.
+- **Defect 2 — two claims the record itself refutes.** *"Cassian was absent from the repo collaborator list"* and *"The grant had to be made by Alexander in the Gitea settings UI and could not be made on his behalf."* He has been on that list since the grant, and the grant **was** made on his behalf: `PUT /api/v1/repos/stackchain/troupe-standup/collaborators/cassian` from `127.0.0.1` → **204** at **2026-10-06T23:49:28Z**, programmatically, no web-UI session anywhere in the logs. The absence sentence is true only as of a stated earlier date.
+- **Defect 3 — a regression on a correction already filed.** The decided note re-asserts *"Timmy had applied it 2026-10-06 ~23:49Z via Gitea API"* and cites **`3ef32bb`** as the documenting commit. `14e69c6` retracts precisely that attribution — *"'applied by Timmy' names an actor that no artifact shows"* — and `3ef32bb` is the **pre-correction** file. The corrected record is `14e69c6` on `decisions/2026-10-07-cassian-write-grant.md`. The relayed file's **later paragraph states this correctly** and cites the correction, so the file now disagrees with itself; the **decided note** is the part to strike.
+- **The edit, mechanically (his file, his append — this queue carries the correction until he applies it; the control plane did not touch his file).** (a) In **evidence**, date-bound the absence claim (*"…absent from the collaborator list as of 2026-10-06 20:47Z, before the grant"*), delete *"no check-ins or commits from him in the pipe as of 2026-10-07"*, and replace the *"had to be made by Alexander in the Gitea settings UI"* sentence with the localhost `PUT` → 204 at 2026-10-06T23:49:28Z. (b) In the **decided note**, replace the *"Timmy had applied it … documented in … commit `3ef32bb`"* clause with: applied 2026-10-06T23:49:28Z with no instruction naming the permission, **ratified** by Alexander's 2026-10-07T21:57:02Z order — see the correction at **`14e69c6`**; the actor is not identifiable from the record. (c) **Fourth item, unflagged:** the Q5 recount's `a2a-workshop` row (*"unverified; Token 404; Timmy cited +4 → 318"*) is superseded — both this host's token and the pipe's read it as **4** issues, so scope-widened the figure is **316**, not 318.
+- **My own bound, named:** *"22h08m"* is a rounded figure. The exact interval from the grant (2026-10-06T23:49:28Z) to the order (2026-10-07T21:57:02Z) is **22 h 07 m 34 s**.
+- **Where the defect is born, and it is not a script this control plane owns.** The relay job I can read (`Human gates submit relay`, default-profile cron, `no_agent`, `script=human_gates_relay.py`, every 5 min, 1,216 B) only prints new human-gates submissions verbatim to Telegram — it does not compose `decisions/*.md`. So the decided-note/evidence text is copied by zephyrus's relay step from the escalated item, and the fix belongs there: quote the item's evidence **as the item's evidence, dated**, and re-check it against live state before restating it as settled record. Flagged for Alexander — not edited here (that cron store is not this profile's).
+- **Standing effect, in the corrected form:** grant applied **2026-10-06T23:49:28Z**, ratified **2026-10-07T21:57:02Z**, `cassian`'s access stands, and the §4 procedural gap (execution without an instruction, actor unidentified) remains open on the record. The two gates the relay names stay Alexander's and are correctly *not* answered by item 28: the wizard credential flow, and the `JOIN-THE-TROUPE.md` onboarding omission.
+- **Nothing new is publishable.** Standing public status unchanged: **15 live / 2 closed / 0 re-posted**.