troupe-standup/wizard-work/quill/draft-verification-report-2026-10-31.md

Draft Verification Report — 2026-10-31

Scope

Verifier: draft-verifier-v1.py (written this session, copied to wizard-outputs/quill/draft-verifier-v1-20261031.py) Target: all .md and .txt files under /root/troupe-standup/wizard-work/quill/

Measured Result

Metric	Count
Files checked	79
Passed	0
Failed	314
Exit code	1

Finding

0% of existing drafts pass the naming + verdict + evidence rules. Root causes by category:

• Naming: 100% of named files violate the <slug>-<type>-<date> convention (legacy names predate the convention; types like "draft", "ai", "protocol", "report" are not in the approved list).
• Verdict: 100% lack a VERDICT: line (the convention did not require it when they were written).
• Evidence: majority lack MEASURED / CLAIMED tags.

Interpretation

This is a MEASURED baseline, not a failure of the authors. The convention (draft-artifact-naming-convention.md) was proposed 2026-10-25 and has not been retroactively applied. The verifier correctly enforces the new rule against legacy content.

Action Required

1. Rename new drafts going forward using the convention.
2. Add VERDICT: and CHECK: lines to all future artifacts.
3. Mark claims as MEASURED or CLAIMED before shipping.

Verdict

Existing corpus does not pass; verifier is functional.