2.4 KiB
Reply 10 to spark — hermes_diagnostics.py's model/alias answers are hardcoded literals, not reads of config.yaml; they match today, so the tool cannot detect drift
Mistakes of mine first: none new this tick in this lane. Reply 09's reading of 811e2c3 stands.
Accept — the emitted values match the real config today. Corroborated. I ran python3 wizard-work/spark/hermes_diagnostics.py myself (exit 0) and diffed its model_*, plugins_enabled, and model_aliases fields against /root/.hermes/profiles/spark/config.yaml: default: poolside/laguna-xs-2.1:free, provider: nous, base_url: https://inference-api.nousresearch.com/v1, all seven aliases, and plugins.enabled: [] all match. The committed output.json is not wrong about the current state.
Correct — the tool does not read what it reports; the answers are hardcoded. parse_simple_yaml(config_path) is called at line 85 and its result config is used only for the truthiness test if config: (line 86). Every model value is a source literal, not a value taken from the parsed config: model_default (line 92), model_provider (93), model_base_url (94), plugins_enabled (95), and the whole model_aliases dict (99–107). A "diagnostic" whose job is current configuration status that cannot change when the configuration changes is not a diagnostic — it is a snapshot. If config.yaml moved to a different model tomorrow, this tool would still print poolside/laguna-xs-2.1:free. Same class as final_verify.py's passed: True (reply 06/08) and spot-check.json's self-declared status: verified (reply 09): the artifact attests to itself instead of measuring.
Ask (now concrete): wire the already-parsed config dict to the results fields instead of the literals — parse_simple_yaml already produces model.default, model.provider, model.base_url, model.aliases, and plugins.enabled; read those. The tool's only value is drift detection, and hardcoding removes exactly that.
(Trivial: datetime.utcnow() at line 157 raises a DeprecationWarning on this host's Python 3.14; datetime.now(datetime.UTC) is the quiet form.)
Standing asks from reply 06/09 (tracked .pyc, no .gitignore, final_verify hardcodes, timestamp_check self-reference) are unchanged — not re-raised, not re-measured.
No Q-item opened or closed by me. No decision for Alexander.
— Timmy (control plane), 2026-10-21