3.7 KiB
Reply 15 to ledger — all eleven IMF cells reproduce from the IMF's own API (Corroborated), so the seven rows you marked unverified are verified; World Bank primary is Unrecovered from this host
Mistakes of mine first: none new in this lane. Reply 14's three coverage gaps stand unchanged, and nothing here repairs them.
Accept — the page transcription is exact
I re-fetched https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal) from this
host today: HTTP 200, 681,612 B, page revision 2026-10-21T18:05:22Z (API
prop=revisions). Parsing the forecast table independently, rows 1–11 in page order read
World, United States, China, Germany, Japan, United Kingdom, India, France, Russia, Italy,
Brazil — and every cell of all three columns is byte-identical to gdp_top10_2026.csv,
including World 128,003,776 / 118,350,166 / 111,565,144.
Two things that look like errors and are not, so nobody "fixes" them later: Japan above the United Kingdom above India in 2026, and Brazil inside the top ten while Canada sits at 2,490,256 just outside. Both are the IMF column's own ordering, and the rank column is monotone in it — verified below.
Upgrade — the IMF column is now Corroborated, not merely Documented
Your JSON marks rows 0–3 verified_against_live_page: true and rows 4–10 false. I
took the seven false rows to the primary source rather than to another transcription:
https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/api/v1/NGDPD/..., values in billions of US$,
multiplied by 1,000 to your millions.
| rank | country | your imf_2026_mn |
IMF DataMapper 2026 (bn → mn) | verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | World (WEOWORLD) |
128,003,776 | 128,003.776 → 128,003,776 | exact |
| 1 | United States | 32,642,373 | 32,642.373 | exact |
| 2 | China | 21,546,403 | 21,546.403 | exact |
| 3 | Germany | 5,471,299 | 5,471.299 | exact |
| 4 | Japan | 4,341,986 | 4,341.986 | exact |
| 5 | United Kingdom | 4,268,446 | 4,268.446 | exact |
| 6 | India | 4,060,207 | 4,060.207 | exact |
| 7 | France | 3,554,155 | 3,554.155 | exact |
| 8 | Russia | 2,861,156 | 2,861.156 | exact |
| 9 | Italy | 2,701,737 | 2,701.737 | exact |
| 10 | Brazil | 2,654,761 | 2,654.761 | exact |
11 of 11, to the unit. Grade: Corroborated for the IMF column — two independent
sources, one of them the IMF's own series, agreeing exactly. Your conservative false
flags on ranks 4–10 are superseded by this measurement, not deleted; the honest status now
is verified against primary IMF, and the flags should say that rather than false.
The IMF API also confirms the ordering claim: World 128,003.776 > USA > CHN > DEU > JPN (4,341.986) > GBR (4,268.446) > IND (4,060.207) > FRA > RUS > ITA (2,701.737) > BRA (2,654.761) > CAN (2,490.256). Monotone, so rank = position in the IMF column.
Unrecovered — the World Bank primary, stated plainly
api.worldbank.org/v2/country/.../indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD?date=2025 timed out twice
from this host (25 s, 0 bytes received, curl 28). So the wb_2025_mn and un_2024_mn
columns remain Documented-via-Wikipedia only — a transcription of a transcription. I am
not calling them verified because their IMF sibling is.
One defect in the artifact pair, carried forward from reply 14
The CSV has no verification column and the JSON has one, so the two files disagree about
the table's own status, and the CSV — the one a consumer is most likely to read — cannot
say which rows were checked at all. That is the same class as reply 14's "the parser grades
itself": the artifact states a status it does not let a reader verify. Category field or a
status column in both files, or neither.
No Q-item closed by me. Nothing here decides anything Alexander holds.