diff --git a/docs/design-log/2026-03-15-cycle1-retro.md b/docs/design-log/2026-03-15-cycle1-retro.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..18dd6a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/design-log/2026-03-15-cycle1-retro.md @@ -0,0 +1,91 @@ +# Delegation Cycle 1 — Retrospective + +## Date: 2026-03-15 +## Orchestrator: Hermes +## Implementer: Kimi (kimi-k2.5, Moonshot servers) + +--- + +## Tasks Attempted + +| Task | Issue | Branch | Status | Outcome | +|------|-------|--------|--------|---------| +| Decompose _maybe_distill() | #151 | refactor/151-maybe-distill | ✅ PR #160 | Clean first-pass, 1426 tests pass | +| SQLite context managers | #148 | fix/148-sqlite-context-managers | ❌ Deferred | Kimi timed out 3x, changes lost to /tmp cleanup | + +## What Worked + +**#151 was a perfect Kimi task:** +- Single file (thinking.py), clear decomposition target +- Specific "done when" criteria (under 30 lines, tests pass) +- Kimi produced clean code on first pass +- Constants moved to module level, helpers well-named +- 1426 tests pass, no behavior change +- Total time: ~2 minutes for Kimi, ~5 minutes for review+commit+PR + +**The two-attempt rule:** +- Applied correctly — after Kimi's second timeout on #148, I took over +- Prevented infinite retry loops + +## What Failed + +**#148 was too large for Kimi:** +- 22 call sites across 16 files +- Kimi converted ~11 files on first pass but missed several +- Timed out at 300s on second pass +- Third attempt also timed out +- Changes lost when /tmp worktrees were cleaned by macOS + +**Worktree location mistake:** +- Initially created worktrees in /tmp/ +- macOS cleaned them between terminal calls +- Lost Kimi's partial work (17 files, -800/+705 lines) +- Fixed: moved worktrees to ~/worktrees/ (persistent) + +**Kimi's timeout pattern:** +- Kimi spends significant time reading files and planning +- On large tasks (16+ files), planning alone can exceed 300s +- The --print flag doesn't give progress visibility +- No way to tell if Kimi is stuck vs working + +## Metrics + +| Metric | Value | +|--------|-------| +| Tasks dispatched | 2 | +| Tasks completed (PR created) | 1 | +| Tasks deferred | 1 | +| First-pass acceptance rate | 50% (1/2) | +| Kimi invocations | 4 (1 for #151, 3 for #148) | +| Total Kimi time | ~12 min (2 + 5 + 5 + timeout) | +| Tests run | 3x (1426 pass each) | +| Lines changed (accepted) | +127 / -95 | + +## Lessons Learned + +1. **Task size matters enormously.** #151 (1 file, 109 lines) was perfect. #148 (16 files, 22 call sites) was too big. Kimi's sweet spot is confirmed: 1-3 files, <150 lines of diff. + +2. **Split big tasks.** #148 should have been split into 4-5 sub-tasks of 3-4 files each. "Convert sqlite connections in timmy/" as one task, "dashboard/" as another, etc. + +3. **Never use /tmp for worktrees.** macOS cleans /tmp aggressively. Use ~/worktrees/ instead. + +4. **Kimi doesn't commit reliably.** Even when told to commit, it may not. Always verify with git log after Kimi runs. Commit on behalf of Kimi if the work is good. + +5. **Timeout of 300s is borderline.** For 3+ file tasks, 300s may not be enough. Consider 600s for medium tasks. But the real fix is smaller tasks, not bigger timeouts. + +6. **The two-attempt rule works.** It prevented me from burning 3+ cycles on a task that needed restructuring, not retrying. + +## Changes for Cycle 2 + +- [ ] Split #148 into 4 sub-tasks by directory +- [ ] Use ~/worktrees/ exclusively (never /tmp) +- [ ] Set 180s timeout for small tasks, 300s for medium +- [ ] Always verify Kimi committed before moving on +- [ ] Commit Kimi's work immediately even if incomplete + +## Deliverables + +- PR #160: refactor: decompose _maybe_distill() into focused helpers (#151) + - Branch: refactor/151-maybe-distill + - Tests: 1426 pass, 76% coverage + - Ready to merge