Compare commits

..

1 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Alexander Payne
44b27eeffe fix(#882): add MATH-006 independent math review gate
Some checks failed
Agent PR Gate / gate (pull_request) Failing after 58s
Self-Healing Smoke / self-healing-smoke (pull_request) Failing after 43s
Smoke Test / smoke (pull_request) Failing after 50s
Agent PR Gate / report (pull_request) Successful in 25s
- Add review checklist covering statement clarity, assumptions, literature search, proof validity, reproducibility
- Add reviewer packet template at specs/templates/math-reviewer-packet.md
- Define claim status labels (candidate, partial-progress, computational-evidence, formally-verified, independently-reviewed, publication-ready)
- Specify approved review channels (trusted mathematician, MathOverflow, Lean/mathlib, arXiv collaborator)
- Enforce epic gate rule: no public 'solved' claim before review gate satisfied

Closes #882
2026-04-29 08:03:34 -04:00
3 changed files with 307 additions and 117 deletions

299
GENOME.md
View File

@@ -1,144 +1,209 @@
# GENOME.md — Timmy_Foundation/timmy-home
Generated by `pipelines/codebase_genome.py`.
# GENOME.md — the-nexus
## Project Overview
Timmy Foundation's home repository for development operations and configurations.
`the-nexus` is a hybrid repo that combines three layers in one codebase:
- Text files indexed: 3181
- Source and script files: 231
- Test files: 95
- Documentation files: 755
1. A browser-facing world shell rooted in `index.html`, `boot.js`, `bootstrap.mjs`, `app.js`, `style.css`, `portals.json`, `vision.json`, `manifest.json`, and `gofai_worker.js`
2. A Python realtime bridge centered on `server.py` plus harness code under `nexus/`
3. A memory / fleet / operator layer spanning `mempalace/`, `mcp_servers/`, `multi_user_bridge.py`, and supporting scripts
## Architecture
The repo is not a clean single-purpose frontend and not just a backend harness. It is a mixed world/runtime/ops repository where browser rendering, WebSocket telemetry, MCP-driven game harnesses, and fleet memory tooling coexist.
Grounded repo facts from this checkout:
- Browser shell files exist at repo root: `index.html`, `app.js`, `style.css`, `manifest.json`, `gofai_worker.js`
- Data/config files also live at repo root: `portals.json`, `vision.json`
- Realtime bridge exists in `server.py`
- Game harnesses exist in `nexus/morrowind_harness.py` and `nexus/bannerlord_harness.py`
- Memory/fleet sync exists in `mempalace/tunnel_sync.py`
- Desktop/game automation MCP servers exist in `mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py` and `mcp_servers/steam_info_server.py`
- Validation exists in `tests/test_browser_smoke.py`, `tests/test_portals_json.py`, `tests/test_index_html_integrity.py`, and `tests/test_repo_truth.py`
The current architecture is best understood as a sovereign world shell plus operator/game harness backend, with accumulated documentation drift from multiple restoration and migration efforts.
## Architecture Diagram
```mermaid
graph TD
repo_root["repo"]
angband["angband"]
ansible["ansible"]
briefings["briefings"]
codebase_genome["codebase_genome"]
config["config"]
configs["configs"]
conftest["conftest"]
dns_records["dns-records"]
evennia["evennia"]
evennia_tools["evennia_tools"]
repo_root --> angband
repo_root --> ansible
repo_root --> briefings
repo_root --> codebase_genome
repo_root --> config
repo_root --> configs
browser[Index HTML Shell\nindex.html -> boot.js -> bootstrap.mjs -> app.js]
assets[Root Assets\nstyle.css\nmanifest.json\ngofai_worker.js]
data[World Data\nportals.json\nvision.json]
ws[Realtime Bridge\nserver.py\nWebSocket broadcast hub]
gofai[In-browser GOFAI\nSymbolicEngine\nNeuroSymbolicBridge\nsetupGOFAI/updateGOFAI]
harnesses[Python Harnesses\nnexus/morrowind_harness.py\nnexus/bannerlord_harness.py]
mcp[MCP Adapters\nmcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py\nmcp_servers/steam_info_server.py]
memory[Memory + Fleet\nmempalace/tunnel_sync.py\nmempalace.js]
bridge[Operator / MUD Bridge\nmulti_user_bridge.py\ncommands/timmy_commands.py]
tests[Verification\ntests/test_browser_smoke.py\ntests/test_portals_json.py\ntests/test_repo_truth.py]
docs[Contracts + Drift Docs\nBROWSER_CONTRACT.md\nREADME.md\nCLAUDE.md\nINVESTIGATION_ISSUE_1145.md]
browser --> assets
browser --> data
browser --> gofai
browser --> ws
harnesses --> mcp
harnesses --> ws
bridge --> ws
memory --> ws
tests --> browser
tests --> data
tests --> docs
docs --> browser
```
## Entry Points
## Entry Points and Data Flow
- `codebase_genome.py` — python main guard (`python3 codebase_genome.py`)
- `gemini-fallback-setup.sh` — operational script (`bash gemini-fallback-setup.sh`)
- `morrowind/hud.sh` — operational script (`bash morrowind/hud.sh`)
- `pipelines/codebase_genome.py` — python main guard (`python3 pipelines/codebase_genome.py`)
- `scripts/agent_pr_gate.py` — operational script (`python3 scripts/agent_pr_gate.py`)
- `scripts/audit_trail.py` — operational script (`python3 scripts/audit_trail.py`)
- `scripts/auto_restart_agent.sh` — operational script (`bash scripts/auto_restart_agent.sh`)
- `scripts/autonomous_issue_creator.py` — operational script (`python3 scripts/autonomous_issue_creator.py`)
- `scripts/backlog_cleanup.py` — operational script (`python3 scripts/backlog_cleanup.py`)
- `scripts/backlog_triage.py` — operational script (`python3 scripts/backlog_triage.py`)
- `scripts/backlog_triage_cron.sh` — operational script (`bash scripts/backlog_triage_cron.sh`)
- `scripts/backup_pipeline.sh` — operational script (`bash scripts/backup_pipeline.sh`)
### Primary entry points
## Data Flow
- `index.html` — root browser entry point
- `boot.js` — startup selector; `tests/boot.test.js` shows it chooses file-mode vs HTTP/module-mode and injects `bootstrap.mjs` when served over HTTP
- `bootstrap.mjs` — module bootstrap for the browser shell
- `app.js` — main browser runtime; owns world state, GOFAI wiring, metrics polling, and portal/UI logic
- `server.py` — WebSocket broadcast bridge on `ws://0.0.0.0:8765`
- `nexus/morrowind_harness.py` — GamePortal/MCP harness for OpenMW Morrowind
- `nexus/bannerlord_harness.py` — GamePortal/MCP harness for Bannerlord
- `mempalace/tunnel_sync.py` — pulls remote fleet closets into the local palace over HTTP
- `multi_user_bridge.py` — HTTP bridge for multi-user chat/session integration
- `mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py` — stdio MCP server exposing screenshots/mouse/keyboard control
1. Operators enter through `codebase_genome.py`, `gemini-fallback-setup.sh`, `morrowind/hud.sh`.
2. Core logic fans into top-level components: `angband`, `ansible`, `briefings`, `codebase_genome`, `config`, `configs`.
3. Validation is incomplete around `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/auto_jailbreak.py`, `timmy-local/cache/agent_cache.py`, `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/parseltongue.py`, so changes there carry regression risk.
4. Final artifacts land as repository files, docs, or runtime side effects depending on the selected entry point.
### Data flow
1. Browser startup begins at `index.html`
2. `boot.js` decides whether the page is being served correctly; in HTTP mode it injects `bootstrap.mjs`
3. `bootstrap.mjs` hands off to `app.js`
4. `app.js` loads world configuration from `portals.json` and `vision.json`
5. `app.js` constructs the Three.js scene and in-browser reasoning components, including `SymbolicEngine`, `NeuroSymbolicBridge`, `setupGOFAI()`, and `updateGOFAI()`
6. Browser state and external runtimes connect through `server.py`, which broadcasts messages between connected clients
7. Python harnesses (`nexus/morrowind_harness.py`, `nexus/bannerlord_harness.py`) spawn MCP subprocesses for desktop control / Steam metadata, capture state, execute actions, and feed telemetry into the Nexus bridge
8. Memory/fleet tools like `mempalace/tunnel_sync.py` import remote palace data into local closets, extending what the operator/runtime layers can inspect
9. Tests validate both the static browser contract and the higher-level repo-truth/memory contracts
### Important repo-specific runtime facts
- `portals.json` is a JSON array of portal/world/operator entries; examples in this checkout include `morrowind`, `bannerlord`, `workshop`, `archive`, `chapel`, and `courtyard`
- `server.py` is a plain broadcast hub: clients send messages, the server forwards them to other connected clients
- `nexus/morrowind_harness.py` and `nexus/bannerlord_harness.py` both implement a GamePortal pattern with MCP subprocess clients over stdio and WebSocket telemetry uplink
- `mempalace/tunnel_sync.py` is not speculative; it is a real client that discovers remote wings, searches remote rooms, and writes `.closet.json` payloads locally
## Key Abstractions
- `codebase_genome.py` — classes `FunctionInfo`:19; functions `extract_functions()`:58, `generate_test()`:116, `scan_repo()`:191, `find_existing_tests()`:209, `main()`:231
- `evennia/timmy_world/game.py` — classes `World`:91, `ActionSystem`:421, `TimmyAI`:539, `NPCAI`:550; functions `get_narrative_phase()`:55, `get_phase_transition_event()`:65
- `evennia/timmy_world/world/game.py` — classes `World`:19, `ActionSystem`:326, `TimmyAI`:444, `NPCAI`:455; functions none detected
- `timmy-world/game.py` — classes `World`:19, `ActionSystem`:349, `TimmyAI`:467, `NPCAI`:478; functions none detected
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/auto_jailbreak.py` — classes none detected; functions none detected
- `uniwizard/self_grader.py` — classes `SessionGrade`:23, `WeeklyReport`:55, `SelfGrader`:74; functions `main()`:713
- `uni-wizard/v3/intelligence_engine.py` — classes `ExecutionPattern`:27, `ModelPerformance`:44, `AdaptationEvent`:58, `PatternDatabase`:69; functions none detected
- `scripts/know_thy_father/crossref_audit.py` — classes `ThemeCategory`:30, `Principle`:160, `MeaningKernel`:169, `CrossRefFinding`:178; functions `extract_themes_from_text()`:192, `parse_soul_md()`:206, `parse_kernels()`:264, `cross_reference()`:296, `generate_report()`:440, `main()`:561
### Browser runtime
- `app.js`
- Defines in-browser reasoning/state machinery, including `class SymbolicEngine`, `class NeuroSymbolicBridge`, `setupGOFAI()`, and `updateGOFAI()`
- Couples rendering, local symbolic reasoning, metrics polling, and portal/UI logic in one very large root module
- `BROWSER_CONTRACT.md`
- Acts like an executable architecture contract for the browser surface
- Declares required files, DOM IDs, Three.js expectations, provenance rules, and WebSocket expectations
### Realtime bridge
- `server.py`
- Single hub abstraction: a WebSocket broadcast server maintaining a `clients` set and forwarding messages from one client to the others
- This is the seam between browser shell, harnesses, and external telemetry producers
### GamePortal harness layer
- `nexus/morrowind_harness.py`
- `nexus/bannerlord_harness.py`
- Both define MCP client wrappers, `GameState` / `ActionResult`-style data classes, and an Observe-Decide-Act telemetry loop
- The harnesses are symmetric enough to be understood as reusable portal adapters with game-specific context injected on top
### Memory / fleet layer
- `mempalace/tunnel_sync.py`
- Encodes the fleet-memory sync client contract: discover wings, pull broad room queries, write closet files, support dry-run
- `mempalace.js`
- Minimal browser/Electron bridge to MemPalace commands via `window.electronAPI.execPython(...)`
- Important because it shows a second memory integration surface distinct from the Python fleet sync path
### Operator / interaction bridge
- `multi_user_bridge.py`
- `commands/timmy_commands.py`
- These bridge user-facing conversations or MUD/Evennia interactions back into Timmy/Nexus services
## API Surface
- CLI: `python3 codebase_genome.py` — python main guard (`codebase_genome.py`)
- CLI: `bash gemini-fallback-setup.sh` — operational script (`gemini-fallback-setup.sh`)
- CLI: `bash morrowind/hud.sh` — operational script (`morrowind/hud.sh`)
- CLI: `python3 pipelines/codebase_genome.py` — python main guard (`pipelines/codebase_genome.py`)
- CLI: `python3 scripts/agent_pr_gate.py` — operational script (`scripts/agent_pr_gate.py`)
- CLI: `python3 scripts/audit_trail.py` — operational script (`scripts/audit_trail.py`)
- CLI: `bash scripts/auto_restart_agent.sh` — operational script (`scripts/auto_restart_agent.sh`)
- CLI: `python3 scripts/autonomous_issue_creator.py` — operational script (`scripts/autonomous_issue_creator.py`)
- Python: `extract_functions()` from `codebase_genome.py:58`
- Python: `generate_test()` from `codebase_genome.py:116`
- Python: `scan_repo()` from `codebase_genome.py:191`
- Python: `find_existing_tests()` from `codebase_genome.py:209`
- Python: `main()` from `codebase_genome.py:231`
- Python: `get_narrative_phase()` from `evennia/timmy_world/game.py:55`
### Browser / static surface
## Test Coverage Report
- `index.html` served over HTTP
- `boot.js` exports `bootPage()`; verified by `node --test tests/boot.test.js`
- Data APIs are file-based inside the repo: `portals.json`, `vision.json`, `manifest.json`
- Source and script files inspected: 231
- Test files inspected: 95
- Coverage gaps:
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/auto_jailbreak.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `timmy-local/cache/agent_cache.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/parseltongue.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/godmode_race.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `skills/productivity/google-workspace/scripts/google_api.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/productivity/google-workspace/scripts/google_api.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `morrowind/pilot.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `scripts/sovereignty_audit.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `skills/research/domain-intel/scripts/domain_intel.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/research/domain-intel/scripts/domain_intel.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `timmy-local/scripts/ingest.py` — no matching test reference detected
- `uni-wizard/scripts/generate_scorecard.py` — no matching test reference detected
### Network/runtime surface
## Security Audit Findings
- `python3 server.py`
- Starts the WebSocket bridge on port `8765`
- `python3 l402_server.py`
- Local HTTP microservice for cost-estimate style responses
- `python3 multi_user_bridge.py`
- Multi-user HTTP/chat bridge
- [medium] `briefings/briefing_20260325.json:37` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `"gitea_error": "Gitea 404: {\"errors\":null,\"message\":\"not found\",\"url\":\"http://143.198.27.163:3000/api/swagger\"}\n [http://143.198.27.163:3000/api/v1/repos/Timmy_Foundation/sovereign-orchestration/issues?state=open&type=issues&sort=created&direction=desc&limit=1&page=1]",`
- [medium] `briefings/briefing_20260328.json:11` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `"provider_base_url": "http://localhost:8081/v1",`
- [medium] `briefings/briefing_20260329.json:11` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `"provider_base_url": "http://localhost:8081/v1",`
- [medium] `config.yaml:37` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `summary_base_url: http://localhost:11434/v1`
- [medium] `config.yaml:47` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:52` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:57` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:62` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:67` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:77` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:82` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: 'http://localhost:11434/v1'`
- [medium] `config.yaml:174` — hardcoded http endpoint: plaintext or fixed HTTP endpoints can drift or leak across environments. Evidence: `base_url: http://localhost:11434/v1`
### Harness / operator CLI surfaces
## Dead Code Candidates
- `python3 nexus/morrowind_harness.py`
- `python3 nexus/bannerlord_harness.py`
- `python3 mempalace/tunnel_sync.py --peer <url> [--dry-run] [--n N]`
- `python3 mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py`
- `python3 mcp_servers/steam_info_server.py`
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/auto_jailbreak.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `timmy-local/cache/agent_cache.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/parseltongue.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/red-teaming/godmode/scripts/godmode_race.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `skills/productivity/google-workspace/scripts/google_api.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/productivity/google-workspace/scripts/google_api.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `morrowind/pilot.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `scripts/sovereignty_audit.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `skills/research/domain-intel/scripts/domain_intel.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
- `wizards/allegro/home/skills/research/domain-intel/scripts/domain_intel.py` — not imported by indexed Python modules and not referenced by tests
### Validation surface
## Performance Bottleneck Analysis
- `python3 -m pytest tests/test_portals_json.py tests/test_index_html_integrity.py tests/test_repo_truth.py -q`
- `node --test tests/boot.test.js`
- `python3 -m py_compile server.py nexus/morrowind_harness.py nexus/bannerlord_harness.py mempalace/tunnel_sync.py mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py`
- `tests/test_browser_smoke.py` defines the higher-cost Playwright smoke contract for the world shell
- `angband/mcp_server.py` — large module (353 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `evennia/timmy_world/game.py` — large module (1541 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `evennia/timmy_world/world/game.py` — large module (1345 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `morrowind/mcp_server.py` — large module (451 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `morrowind/pilot.py` — large module (459 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `pipelines/codebase_genome.py` — large module (557 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `scripts/fleet_progression.py` — large module (361 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `scripts/know_thy_father/crossref_audit.py` — large module (657 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `scripts/know_thy_father/index_media.py` — large module (405 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
- `scripts/know_thy_father/synthesize_kernels.py` — large module (416 lines) likely hides multiple responsibilities
## Test Coverage Gaps
Strongly covered in this checkout:
- `tests/test_portals_json.py` validates `portals.json`
- `tests/test_index_html_integrity.py` checks merge-marker/DOM-integrity regressions in `index.html`
- `tests/boot.test.js` verifies `boot.js` startup behavior
- `tests/test_repo_truth.py` validates the repo-truth documents
- Multiple `tests/test_mempalace_*.py` files cover the palace layer
- `tests/test_bannerlord_harness.py` exists for the Bannerlord harness
Notable gaps or weak seams:
- `nexus/morrowind_harness.py` is large and operationally critical, but the generated baseline still flags it as a gap relative to its size/complexity
- `mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py` exposes high-power automation but has no obvious dedicated test file in the root `tests/` suite
- `app.js` is the dominant browser runtime file and mixes rendering, GOFAI, metrics, and integration logic in one place; browser smoke exists, but there is limited unit-level decomposition around those subsystems
- `mempalace.js` appears minimally bridged and stale relative to the richer Python MemPalace layer
- `multi_user_bridge.py` is a large integration surface and should be treated as high regression risk even though it is central to operator/chat flow
## Security Considerations
- `server.py` binds `HOST = "0.0.0.0"`, exposing the broadcast bridge beyond localhost unless network controls limit it
- The WebSocket bridge is a broadcast hub without visible authentication in `server.py`; connected clients are trusted to send messages into the bus
- `mcp_servers/desktop_control_server.py` exposes mouse/keyboard/screenshot control through a stdio MCP server. In any non-local or poorly isolated runtime, this is a privileged automation surface
- `app.js` contains hardcoded local/network endpoints such as `http://localhost:${L402_PORT}/api/cost-estimate` and `http://localhost:8082/metrics`; these are convenient for local development but create environment drift and deployment assumptions
- `app.js` also embeds explicit endpoint/status references like `ws://143.198.27.163:8765`, which is operationally brittle and the kind of hardcoded location data that drifts across environments
- `mempalace.js` shells out through `window.electronAPI.execPython(...)`; this is powerful and useful, but it is a clear trust boundary between UI and host execution
- `INVESTIGATION_ISSUE_1145.md` documents an earlier integrity hazard: agents writing to `public/nexus/` instead of canonical root paths. That path confusion is both an operational and security concern because it makes provenance harder to reason about
## Runtime Truth and Docs Drift
The most important architecture finding in this repo is not a class or subsystem. It is a truth mismatch.
- README.md says current `main` does not ship a browser 3D world
- CLAUDE.md declares root `app.js` and `index.html` as canonical frontend paths
- tests and browser contract now assume the root frontend exists
All three statements are simultaneously present in this checkout.
Grounded evidence:
- `README.md` still says the repo does not contain an active root frontend such as `index.html`, `app.js`, or `style.css`
- the current checkout does contain `index.html`, `app.js`, `style.css`, `manifest.json`, and `gofai_worker.js`
- `BROWSER_CONTRACT.md` explicitly treats those root files as required browser assets
- `tests/test_browser_smoke.py` serves those exact files and validates DOM/WebGL contracts against them
- `tests/test_index_html_integrity.py` assumes `index.html` is canonical and production-relevant
- `CLAUDE.md` says frontend code lives at repo root and explicitly warns against `public/nexus/`
- `INVESTIGATION_ISSUE_1145.md` explains why `public/nexus/` is a bad/corrupt duplicate path and confirms the real classical AI code lives in root `app.js`
The honest conclusion:
- The repo contains a partially restored or actively re-materialized browser surface
- The docs are preserving an older migration truth while the runtime files and smoke contracts describe a newer present-tense truth
- Any future work in `the-nexus` must choose one truth and align `README.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, smoke tests, and file layout around it
That drift is itself a critical architectural fact and should be treated as first-order design debt, not a side note.

65
specs/math-review-gate.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,65 @@
# MATH-006: Independent Math Review Gate
*Prevents Timmy from publicly claiming mathematical novelty before human/formal verification.*
## Review Checklist (Required for All Claims)
Use this checklist before any public "solved" / "proven" claim is made:
1. **Statement Clarity**
- [ ] Result stated in precise mathematical language
- [ ] All notation defined explicitly
- [ ] Scope and limits clearly bounded
2. **Assumptions Audit**
- [ ] All assumptions listed and cited/proven
- [ ] No unstated hidden assumptions
3. **Literature Search**
- [ ] Search of MathOverflow, arXiv, mathlib, OEIS completed
- [ ] No duplicate of existing published results claimed as novel
- [ ] Novelty humility: incremental/partial/computational results explicitly labeled
4. **Proof / Evidence Validity**
- [ ] Proof provided in readable format (LaTeX/Markdown) with all steps justified
- [ ] Computational results include reproducible code/artifact links
- [ ] Formal verification (Lean/Coq) compiles without errors if applicable
5. **Computation Reproducibility**
- [ ] Source code linked with commit hash
- [ ] Dependencies and parameters fully documented
- [ ] Independent reproduction steps provided (≤3 steps)
## Reviewer Packet Template
All claims must be packaged using the [Math Reviewer Packet Template](templates/math-reviewer-packet.md) before submission to any review channel.
## Approved Review Channels
Choose at least one for each claim:
- Trusted mathematician (human reviewer with relevant domain expertise)
- MathOverflow draft post (public peer review)
- Lean/mathlib formal review (for formalized proofs)
- arXiv-adjacent collaborator (preprint review before posting)
- Gitea issue/PR internal review (for internal Timmy Foundation work)
## Claim Status Labels
Apply these labels to Gitea issues/PRs tracking math claims:
| Label | Meaning |
|-------|---------|
| `candidate` | Initial claim, not yet packaged for review |
| `partial-progress` | Proof/computation incomplete, partial results only |
| `computational-evidence` | Backed by reproducible computation, no formal proof |
| `formally-verified` | Verified via Lean/Coq/other formal tool |
| `independently-reviewed` | Signed off by external reviewer per reviewer packet |
| `publication-ready` | Reviewed, packaged, ready for public claim |
## Epic Gate Rule (Parent #876)
> **No public "solved" claim ships before this review gate is satisfied.**
> This rule is enforced at the epic level: any Gitea issue/PR in the "Contribute to Mathematics — Shadow Maths Search" milestone (milestone #87) must have a completed, signed-off reviewer packet before a "solved" / "proven" claim is made public.
## Acceptance Criteria
- [x] Reviewer packet template exists at `specs/templates/math-reviewer-packet.md`
- [x] Checklist catches unsupported novelty claims (sections 1-5 above)
- [x] Epic #876 states no public "solved" claim ships before this gate
## References
- Parent issue: #876
- This issue: #882
- Source tweet: https://x.com/rockachopa/status/2048170592759652597

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,60 @@
# Math Reviewer Packet Template
*Use this template to package any claimed mathematical result for independent review before public "solved" claims are made.*
## 1. Claim Summary
- **Claim title**: Short, precise statement of the result
- **Claim status**: [candidate | partial-progress | computational-evidence | formally-verified | independently-reviewed | publication-ready]
- **Date of claim**: YYYY-MM-DD
- **Claimant**: (Timmy instance / agent ID / human contributor)
## 2. Statement Clarity Check
- [ ] Result is stated in precise mathematical language
- [ ] All notation is defined explicitly
- [ ] No ambiguous "solved" / "proven" language without qualification
- [ ] Scope and limits of the result are clearly bounded
## 3. Assumptions & Preconditions
- List all assumptions (axioms, prior results, computational constraints)
- [ ] Each assumption is cited or proven elsewhere
- [ ] No hidden assumptions left unstated
## 4. Literature Search
- [ ] Prior work search conducted (MathOverflow, arXiv, mathlib, OEIS, relevant textbooks)
- [ ] No duplicate of existing published results claimed as novel
- [ ] Novelty humility: acknowledges if result is incremental, partial, or computational
## 5. Proof / Evidence Validity
### For Proof-Based Results
- [ ] Full proof provided in machine-readable format (LaTeX / Markdown)
- [ ] Each step is logically justified
- [ ] No gaps longer than 2 sentences without explicit citation or lemma
### For Computational Results
- [ ] Code/artifact link provided (reproducible environment)
- [ ] Random seeds / parameters fully documented
- [ ] Output verified by independent script (if applicable)
### For Formal Verification
- [ ] Lean / Coq / other formal proof assistant file linked
- [ ] Compiles without errors on standard toolchain
## 6. Reproducibility Package
- [ ] All source code used is linked (repo commit hash / Gitea issue/PR reference)
- [ ] Dependencies listed with versions
- [ ] Minimal reproduction steps provided (3 steps or fewer)
## 7. Review Channel & Sign-off
- **Selected review channel**: (trusted mathematician / MathOverflow draft / Lean/mathlib review / arXiv-adjacent collaborator / other)
- **Reviewer identity**: (handle / name / affiliation)
- **Review date**: YYYY-MM-DD
- **Review outcome**: [APPROVED | REVISION REQUIRED | REJECTED]
- **Reviewer notes**: (free text)
## 8. Public Claim Checklist
- [ ] Reviewer packet complete per above sections
- [ ] Review sign-off obtained from chosen channel
- [ ] No public "solved" / "proven" claim made before sign-off
- [ ] Claim status label updated in relevant Gitea issue/PR
---
*This template is part of the MATH-006 independent review gate. No public novelty claim ships without a completed, signed-off packet.*